A lot of people come to Zen because they have serious apprehensions about the religious path they grew up with. That was me. I thought Zen meditation was the answer to all my problems when I met my teacher. But my teacher never affirmed this idea. Instead, she said, “Zen doesn’t make you into a Buddhist. Zen aims to make us better at being ourself. If you are Christian, you’ll be a better Christian.”
Whoa! I didn’t expect to hear an affirmation of Christianity and of God coming from a Buddhist priest. For many people it seems almost heretical to doubt your faith tradition, or to find truth outside of it. As soon as you go down that road it’s as though you have “lost your faith.” So, we are presented, all too often, with only two choices when we start to have doubts about our faith: 1) Embrace it fully and never look back. 2) Reject it completely. Both these options, while important aspects of the spiritual journey, are not enough.
Both paths play into our own insecurities. For those who embrace their faith when encountered with doubt, there is a profound closed-mindedness that is easy to recognize from the outside. Such folks get heaps of criticism about being ultra conservative in their views. I’d suggest, however, that this stance is an important part of the spiritual path, not separate from it. It can be inspirational to meet people with such faith and certainty in a religion even when that religion may be highly criticized by outsiders. There is something to be said about sticking with something even in the midst of “fire.” There is the virtue of loyalty that is so often missing in our society. While criticism of any religion is warranted, respecting a devout person for firmly standing within their understanding of religion is also important.
Human development follows a similar kind of path. When we are children, we see everything in black and white. The words and admonishments of our parents are like God speaking to us. Parents teach us right and wrong, directing us for our own protection. Parents put up gates at the stairs, for example, so that the baby doesn’t tumble down accidentally. The gate is there to prevent the baby who is not yet ready to walk, from seriously injuring themselves. Just as we don’t disrespect babies for not having the ability to walk, we ought to be very careful about judging people who have firmly held religious convictions despite what may appear to us to be illogical. Those convictions may serve as a kind of “child safety gate,” and I don’t mean this pejoratively.
Yet eventually we learn how to walk, and the gate no longer serves its original purpose. In Buddhist terminology we say, “Once we get to the other shore, we can discard the raft that got us there.” We need a raft to get over to the other shore of Enlightenment. But once we are on the other shore, we need to let go of the raft. It’s served its purpose. (We might even need it in the future at some point to help others across). Strongly held beliefs serve a purpose for a person. We don’t know the kind of “troubled waters” such a person may be navigating through unless we get to know that person well.
The second path is far more common in modern times: the complete rejection of all religious paths. In its extreme form this may take the shape of addiction. The addiction has its purpose, though. The addiction fills the void in one’s life. The absence of feeling a connection to something greater than oneself, gets temporarily filled by the addiction. Excessive drugs, alcohol, and work are examples. There’s nothing wrong with these things in moderation. We are not unethical by choosing to use drugs, for example. What’s missing, however, is that innate, birthright of our continual connection with the divine or with love, or however you want to call it. We may feel we need to pay for something that was ours all along!
Many of us are implicitly taught that religion = certainty. As soon as some leaks are found in the raft, people “throw the baby out with the bathwater” without a second thought. I did that. If the religion has problems inside of it, then the whole thing must be wrong or have no relevance for my life.
This is part of the spiritual path, too, though. Rejection of religion is a religious path. It’s a start. There’s an acknowledgment of the importance of living our life without having the dictates of someone else to follow. These folks often have a hard time with the “rules” of a religion, and justifiably. If they are young, their body is telling them to seek out sensual pleasure or sex, but the religion says sex is bad outside marriage. There’s a disconnect between what the religion says and their physiological reality. They’ve chosen not to suppress basic desires and have, unfortunately, rejected religion in the process. Or, perhaps, their parents already rejected it for them, and they didn’t have the opportunity to make their own choice about it. In either case, while it’s a part of the path to reject religion either completely or in part, it stunts spiritual growth if we don’t (eventually) question that rejection.
There is another way to approach religion, however, that moves us to the possibility of deepening our understanding of the purpose of religion, and of a sense of meaning that goes beyond dualistic thinking. That is by giving primary attention to the things in the tradition that make sense and to disregard that which is not true to your own experience, regardless of what someone who calls themselves an “authority” says. Growth happens in “wrestling” with God, in questioning our ideas of God and purpose, and in having the confidence to respectfully doubt what the tradition has handed down to us, but to not completely abandon it under the guise of self-righteousness.
Even Zen Buddhism can be problematic in terms of not questioning authority. Yet we should question the authorities of the tradition, including Zen Master Dogen. Dogen says in his instructions for zazen, for example, “Do not doubt the true dragon.” This pithy saying in his “universal” instructions can be misleading. The “true dragon” is referring to zazen (or, perhaps, to a teacher). Should we never question or doubt the utility of zazen for our life nor how to do it? Nor his instructions?
The 16 Bodhisattva Precepts of the Zen path can also be problematic in some ways, and for us not to question them because we would be going against what is “good” and “ethical,” as if they were commandments, is falling into another trap. For example, the precepts say we should refrain from disparaging the Three Treasures – Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha, and from disparaging the wrongs of others. While the sentiment for such precepts is to keep our overly critical mind in check, sometimes it’s important to call out misbehavior in a sangha member. But for this, we need a sangha culture that does not punish people for speaking up about their misgivings nor about abuses of power.
In other words, even Zen, though it is a chosen path for most of us, needs to be critically evaluated and doubted. We need not enter the Zendo with blind faith in the attributes of zazen, the teachings, and the Sangha.
Furthermore, many people come to Zen from traumatic religious associations and need the space to doubt what they are being taught to think and act. Having sensitivity to this is part of becoming a mature sangha.
One place that I notice students having trouble is in distinguishing between the “rules” (or Zendo forms) of Soto Zen on the one hand, and ethical behavior (Bodhisattva precepts) on the other. The forms sometimes become conflated with ethics. So, for example, some new students may feel that if you don’t bow correctly upon entering the Zendo, then you will be punished in some way by a spiritual power, Buddha, God, or someone. Newcomers are presented with a host of instructions on how to walk, sit, bow, chant, and greet others. If they do these things “correctly” then they may come to feel they have attained some kind of salvation through these motions. If they do them “incorrectly” then they may act as though they need salvation, (I often listen to apologies for not ringing the bell correctly as if someone was hurt by their lapse of attention) or they outrightly reject the forms and never return to the Zen center again. This conflating of the Zen forms with more general ethical behavior such as “promote life,” “practice generosity,” or “be of service,” happens way too often and is sad to see.
A way forward from this conundrum is by seeing the forms as opportunities to deepen mindfulness. When they are not done “correctly” there’s no judgment involved. Rather, there is noticing an opportunity to generate mindfulness in that very moment. Bringing hands into shashu (folded hands), for example, is a way to call attention to what we are doing in that moment. It’s not a practice that leads to mindfulness. Rather, it is mindful activity (as long as it doesn’t get habituated and done mindlessly). We can use the shashu gesture as a way to become curious about our walking, our body, our feelings, and the external world, perhaps noticing something that we never noticed before. When practiced in this way, the forms are used as they were meant to be: to generate a collective mindfulness that has the possibility for true healing of the confused mind.
Lucky for us, doubt has always been an important part of the Zen path. It’s considered a positive mental state. Doubt has the power to raise the Beginner’s Mind. Doubt is promoted by the Buddha when he said in the Kalama Sutta, “Don’t do what I say just because I said it. Put what I say into practice to determine whether it is helpful for relieving suffering.” Then you can discard it if it’s not helpful. Doubts and questions should be brought forward in the process of investigating any Buddhist instructions that may be confusing or contradictory, or just don’t “feel” right. It’s alright to doubt the true dragon.